Pros and cons of debt consolidation
Debt consolidation can genuinely help in the right circumstances and make things worse in the wrong ones. Here is an honest look at both sides so you can judge it for your own situation.
Request a free quote
No obligationTell us what you would like to consolidate and we will be in touch. We will never ask for bank passwords or card details.
The pros and cons at a glance
Before the detail, here is the short version. The panels below set the main advantages against the main risks so you can see the shape of the decision at once.
Where it can help
- One monthly repayment instead of several to track
- A single due date, reducing the risk of a missed payment
- Possibly a lower interest rate than some existing debts
- A fixed end date, so you know when you will be debt-free
- Potentially lower monthly outgoings, easing a tight budget
Where it can hurt
- A longer term can mean much more interest overall
- Arrangement and early-repayment fees can erode savings
- It does not address why the debt built up
- Freed-up credit cards can tempt you to borrow again
- Securing debt on your home puts the property at risk
What are the main advantages of consolidating debt?
The clearest benefit is simplicity. Managing one repayment is easier than juggling several, and fewer due dates means fewer chances to miss one, which protects your credit file. If the consolidation loan carries a lower rate than the debts it replaces, and the term is sensible, you may also cut the cost of your borrowing. And because most consolidation loans run for a fixed term, you gain a definite end point. Open-ended credit-card debt, where minimum payments can stretch on for years, offers nothing of the sort. There is a quieter benefit too: knowing exactly what leaves your account and when can take some of the stress out of managing money, which matters when debt has started to feel overwhelming.
What are the drawbacks and risks of a consolidation loan?
The biggest risk is paying more overall. Lowering the monthly payment by extending the term feels like relief, but you hold the money for longer and the total interest climbs. Fees can make matters worse, so always read the full cost rather than the headline rate. It is worth remembering, too, that a longer run of smaller payments keeps you in debt for more years, even when each month feels easier at the time. Consolidation also treats a symptom rather than a cause: if spending consistently outstrips income, a new loan can delay the problem and deepen it. And moving unsecured debt onto a secured loan changes its nature entirely, as the section below explains.
Securing debt against your home
A secured consolidation loan can lead to repossession of your home if you fall behind. Turning credit-card or loan debt, which is not tied to your home, into debt that is, is a serious step that deserves careful thought and, ideally, independent advice.
Does consolidating still help if the rate is about the same?
It can, though the case is weaker. If the new loan does not undercut your existing rates, the benefit is mostly about order rather than cost: one payment, one date, one end point. That convenience has real value if a cluttered set of payments is causing missed dates and late fees. But if the rate is similar and the term is longer, you could end up paying more for the tidiness. Work out the total you would repay either way before deciding whether the simplicity is worth it.
Who does debt consolidation suit, and who should avoid it?
Consolidation is not right or wrong in the abstract; it depends on your circumstances. The two groups below sit at opposite ends.
May suit someone who…
- Can get a lower rate or more manageable payment
- Has a stable, affordable budget going forward
- Wants a clear, fixed repayment plan
- Will not run the cleared balances back up
May not suit someone who…
- Is already struggling to afford repayments
- Would only extend the term and pay more
- Is likely to keep borrowing on cleared accounts
- Has priority debts better handled another way
If you are unsure, read whether debt consolidation is a good idea and the common mistakes to avoid, or weigh up the alternatives.
How can you make consolidation work in your favour?
If you decide a loan is right for you, a few habits tip the balance towards the benefits rather than the risks:
- Compare the total amount repayable, not just the monthly figure
- Keep the term as short as you can comfortably afford
- Resist running cleared balances back up
- Check for fees before you sign, and factor them into the cost
Free, impartial help is available from MoneyHelper, StepChange and Citizens Advice.
Common questions about the pros and cons
Is debt consolidation a good idea?
It depends on your circumstances. It helps most when it lowers your costs or makes payments manageable and you can keep to a budget. It helps least when it only stretches the term or frees up credit you will use again. See is it a good idea.
Does consolidating debt hurt your credit score?
Applying involves a credit search, and a new account can dip your score at first. Over time, keeping up payments on one loan and clearing other balances can help, provided you do not fall behind.
Can consolidation save me money?
It can, if the new loan carries a lower rate and a sensible term and the fees do not outweigh the saving. Always compare the total amount repayable, not just the monthly payment.
What is the biggest risk?
Paying more overall by extending the term, and, with a secured loan, putting your home at risk. Both are avoidable with careful comparison, but both are easy to overlook when a lower monthly payment is the focus.
Will I be tempted to borrow again afterwards?
That is a real risk once cards are cleared. Many people find it helps to close or lock away the old accounts, so the freed-up credit is not sitting there to be spent.